Reference Check Software

Reference Check Questions: 20+ Questions to Ask and What to Avoid

S
SaaSPodium Editorial TeamUpdated:
Reference Check Questions: 20+ Questions to Ask and What to Avoid - SaaSPodium

Advertisement

Good reference check questions focus on job-related behavior, results and working style, and are asked the same way for every candidate. Ask about role, strengths, areas to develop, collaboration and rehire eligibility, and avoid questions on protected characteristics. Reference check software can standardize and automate this process.

Reference checks are most useful when they test claims from the resume and interview with specific evidence. Vague questions get vague answers. Structured, consistent questions give you comparable information across candidates and reduce bias.

Fairness matters as much as insight. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission publishes guidance for employers on avoiding discrimination in hiring, and SHRM offers HR practice resources. Always involve legal counsel for local rules. Tools that automate the process are listed in the Reference Check Software category, and our reference check best practices guide covers process design.

How to Prepare Before You Ask

Prepare by defining the three to five competencies that matter most for the role, then write questions that test each one. This keeps calls short and focused on what predicts success.

Get the candidate's written permission, confirm the referee's relationship to the candidate, and tell referees how the information will be used. Take notes in a shared template so different reviewers record answers consistently.

  • Pick competencies: for example ownership, collaboration, communication and technical skill.
  • Choose referees: aim for a manager and a peer or direct report where possible.
  • Schedule 15 minutes: short calls get better completion than long ones.

Opening Questions to Verify the Relationship

Start by confirming how the referee knows the candidate and the facts of the role. These questions anchor the rest of the conversation and catch inflated titles or dates.

Keep them neutral and factual, and record the answers as written. If dates or titles differ from the resume, note the gap and raise it respectfully with the candidate rather than assuming bad faith. Small discrepancies often come from title changes, contract roles or company renames.

  • How do you know the candidate, and for how long did you work together?
  • What was the candidate's role and main responsibilities?
  • What were the dates of employment, if you are able to confirm them?

Performance and Results Questions

Ask about outcomes and examples rather than opinions, because evidence is easier to compare across candidates than impressions. Requests for a specific situation produce better evidence than asking whether the person was good.

Follow up with 'what happened next' to reach details a rehearsed answer would skip.

  • Describe a project where the candidate delivered strong results. What was their contribution?
  • How did the candidate handle tight deadlines or changing priorities?
  • How would you describe the quality and reliability of their work?
  • What were the candidate's strongest skills in this role?

Collaboration and Leadership Questions

These questions reveal how the person works with others, which is hard to see in interviews. Look for patterns across referees rather than a single comment.

For leadership roles, ask about the outcomes teams achieved, not only about management style.

  • How did the candidate work with colleagues, customers or other departments?
  • How did they respond to feedback or disagreement?
  • If they led others, how did their team members describe working for them?
  • How did they communicate progress and problems?

Development and Rehire Questions

Closing questions invite balanced feedback and often yield the most useful signal about fit and growth. People tend to be candid when asked about growth rather than weaknesses.

Rehire eligibility is a simple, comparable data point, if the referee is permitted to share it.

  • In what areas could the candidate grow, and what support would help them succeed?
  • What kind of manager or environment brings out their best work?
  • Would you work with or rehire this person, and why?
  • Is there anything else we should know to help them succeed?

Questions to Avoid

Avoid any question about age, race, religion, gender, pregnancy, disability, family plans, national origin or other protected characteristics, since they create legal risk and add no job-related signal. Stay focused on job-related facts and behaviors.

Rules differ by country and state, so confirm your questions with legal counsel or HR leadership. Document that every candidate received the same core questions.

  • Do not ask: about health, marital status, children or religion.
  • Do not push: if a referee declines to answer, note it and move on.
  • Do not decide alone: combine references with interviews and assessments.

When to Use Reference Check Software

Software helps when you run many checks, need consistent questions or want faster turnaround. Referees complete online questionnaires on their own schedule instead of arranging calls.

SaaSPodium lists tools including SkillSurvey, Xref, Crosschq and Searchlight, plus options for small teams such as AutoRefs. See the SkillSurvey website as an example, and confirm features, integrations with your ATS and pricing with each vendor.

  • Standard templates: the same questions by role and level.
  • Automation: reminders to referees and status tracking for recruiters.
  • ATS integration: results saved to the candidate record.
  • Consent and privacy: clear candidate consent and data retention controls.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many references should I check per candidate?
Two to three is common, ideally including a recent manager and a peer. More references add effort with diminishing returns, so spend time on well-prepared questions rather than a higher count.

Is reference check software worth it for a small company?
It can be, if you hire regularly and want consistent, faster checks. For occasional hiring, a shared question template and calls may be enough. Compare vendor pricing against recruiter time saved.

How long should a reference check take?
A phone reference usually takes about 15 minutes. Software-based questionnaires often finish within a few days because referees answer on their own schedule, so build that time into your hiring plan.

Advertisement